Talk:Hull's Sword/@comment-220.253.151.46-20151112051501/@comment-6896023-20151212134305

I just did some testing of my own, and you are partially correct. It seems that both Charisma and Reputation are actors, but more testing needs to be done to determine precisely how it all works. A character of most Alignments (I tested with CE, LE and LG, for now) will get the best result with a Charisma of 16 regardless of Reputation. However, my Lawful Neutral character with 17 Charisma did not receive it, as you said. After increasing his Reputation to 18 (I'll test later with other levels), he got the good outcome. For my last test, I used a Chaotic Good character with a Reputation of 18 and 14 Charisma, and he got the good result as well. Like I said, though, this still needs more tesing.