Talk:The Fishermen and the Priestess/@comment-98.228.177.250-20160509052931/@comment-240F:CF:DDC6:1:D1C4:AD05:2E17:A68C-20181107152241

For the sake of any who read this later, the likely issue here is that she will turn hostile if you attack her again after she asks you to get the bowl, and if you have the AI turned on, there's a high chance that will happen. Once that happens, there is no way to finish the quest(not even using Charm Person worked). So what you need to do is turn off the AI before you speak with her, and then pause immediately after she ends the fight with dialogue and click away from her so any ongoing attacks are interrupted.