User blog comment:Inain/Viconia's dilemma/@comment-3418306-20161031215232/@comment-28867724-20161119155758

Well, I think I get your point and the chart is really nice. The only thing that haunts me is that your answers seem to rely on external circumstances to the fact itself. What the player possesses as certain information is that a Flaming Fist guy says he will killl "that woman" right away and you should face the decision of letting him do it or not. As the player has no proof either way, he risks that letting the FF kill her will be a mistake, while letting her live will guide him to kill the FF and probably letting a murderer stay alive. But the FF pushes the decision that way, as he is decided to kill Viconia. So, while the player tries to avoid a possible evil action (FF killing her) he risks doing an evil acton (killing FF and saving a murderer). Nonetheless, my point is that the player has to do that, as the first problem is if he should let the FF kill her, which in my point of view he shouldn't.

Of course, the player can decide to do nothing, but then his moral conscioussness is not responding to the challenge.

I think all the problem resides in the FF attitude of killing immediately the woman and not taking her to prision.