User blog comment:Inain/Viconia's dilemma/@comment-3418306-20161031215232

Not gonna lie - I kinda hate these morality mixups, and game devs seems to really enjoy inserting at least one into every RPG, just so that the 'good' characters will be damned either way. I generally fall back on canon *spoilers?*, and as Viconia is alive and well in BG2, I assume any interaction in BG1 leaves her amongst the living ...which basically requires killing the merc, which you pointedly don't receive a hit to your reputation for doing so, which is somewhat telling in-and-of itself. At the end of the day, she is an evil drow, and while other drow have risen above the stereotype (Ex; Drizzit), it seems obvious that Viconia isn't one of them, whether or not she's guilty of the supposed 'murder'.

Alternatively, I'd just avoid that section of that area entirely so I don't even have to deal with it... aHA!